So I am in Seattle taking a couple of extra days before regrouping and heading back home to the regularly scheduled mania of the summer performing schedule and 18th Anniversary Concert pre-production AND dealing with more logistics around the death of my Dad and what it all means, including preparing for the burial of his ashes on Sunday.
Definitely not my best week, and perhaps this wouldn’t rank high on my list of best years, either, although it’s definitely had its better moments.
It just so happens that the timeshare property I am at is fairly well kitty-corner to the Paramount Theatre and the World Premiere of Mel Brooks’ new musical adaptation of Young Frankenstein is currently in production there. It struck me that it might be a good idea to try to go see it, but I was very apprehensive about the prospect.
At this point I have to explain that Young Frankenstein is the first movie I can remember going to see with my parents. Surely there had been others, but this is the one that stands out in my mind. In 1974 I would have been 7 years old and this would have been right before my parents split up. It was the first of many Mel Brooks movies that I would eventually get to see, with either and sometimes both (respectively, not together with) my parents.
I think in some ways it was perhaps a cornerstone of the foundation of the formation of my…sense of humor…or sense of comedic timing, at the very least. Looking up at the marquee, I would shake my head with a fair bit of consternation, incapable of imagining a better cast than Gene Wilder, Madeline Kahn, Marty Feldman, Teri Garr, Kenneth Mars and Gene Hackman (to name only a few). Not wanting to eventually walk away from the theatre muttering with the same amount of disappointment I felt about the surprise Elven army at Helm’s Deep, I mostly did my best to talk myself out of going.
But it was a splendid opportunity, like seeing The Producers in Chicago. I wouldn’t have gotten to see that if it hadn’t been for Marco, actually, and I knew Marco had gotten tickets and come to see this show…so…on a whim I got in line and I called him and was lucky enough to catch him and ask him what he thought (you’ll have to ask him yourself ifyou’re that interested). Then I was determined to get a ticket but, overhearing the transaction ahead of me, it seemed the seating options were limited. What to do!? It turned out I was able to get a ticket from someone who had an extra ticket. I ended up paying a dollar less than it would have cost me than if I’d bought the ticket online since neither of us had the right amount of change. I also ended up sitting Balcony, First Row, Center! I could have paid more to sit much further back, but didn’t have to. That was a true blessing, especially given the amount of the ticket in fact represents a fair percentage of my monthly discretionary income (read as grocery $).
It’s beyond justifiable, however, in my mind. In fact, it’s critical to be able to see a production like this, especially given that I occasionally perform, produce and direct shows in theatres just like this — not that I want my shows to end up anything like a Mel Brooks musical. It’s just good to know how one plays out on stage, and it’s way cheaper and easier to see a show in a venue like this than trying to get a ticket once it becomes a smash hit on Broadway. What would really be great would be being able to see it on opening night and then a few more times as things are worked out, and then see it in New York. That sort of thing would be invaluable on so many levels. It’s way outta my budget range, though.
Oh, and given the audience’s response, it IS going to be a smash hit on Broadway. Get up to Seattle if you can.
Still and all, I did get a great ticket and I did see a great show.
The plot is basically the same, but it was hard for me to let go of the original storyline, and some of the greatest and most iconic lines seemed rushed to me. I wished the actors had taken more time with them. I don’t think that I wanted an imitation of them, and please understand I and some of my closest friends quote them frequently to add color and humor to random events in our lives, or we simply to break the tedium, knowing that they will usually garner a laugh or a smile.
The timing of the lines in the film was so…impeccable…in the original performances of them. I want these stage actors to make them as potent as they feel when I am saying them in casual conversation, but it’s almost like these actors don’t quite own the words just yet. Maybe as the run progresses they will feel and bring out more of the magic, raw energy and humor in them a bit more.
I don’t envy them, though. There’s definitely a challenge in performing something so well-known, and to carry forward the most beloved characteristics of the characters/parts while bringing in one’s own interpretation and unique style into the role based on the demands of the changing context and the contemporary audience…where the performance also has to stand on its own considering a lot of people who never saw the movie will be seeing this show.
There are a few other jarring things for me.
The melody has gone missing — the one played on violin and french horn, that I coincidentally whistle to call my cat when she’s wandered off. I am left to wonder if there was there a copyright issue there or if no one else cares quite as much as I do about the tune.
The special effects are great but a few of the strobe flashes were paced in such a way I was having visions of folks going into convulsions. The way the second half played out felt, loose, somehow…where the plot elements are switched around a bit and the contexts change a little and things are wrapped up well enough but also not as cleanly as they had been before (to my way of thinking). It was more evident in the second half than the first, and it could just be because the plot of the movie is implanted in my head and deviations from it are slightly confusing, or it could be something that could be tightened up, somehow, but I’d have to see the production a few more times to try and pinpoint it.
Then there’s the fact that it’s a musical. Don’t get me wrong. I like musicals. I generally like Mel Brooks’ lyrics, too. I am more recently spoiled by Sondheim, though. There’s a number called Please Don’t Touch Me and I can’t help but think the grammar is wonky, where the chorus should be negating a proactive action referenced in the verse, but in some cases is redundant to what has just been sung in a double-negative sort of way. I don’t want there to be any spoilers, so that’s about as specific as that’s going to get. I had to make a concerted effort to say to myself, “This is a musical. Judge it on its merits as a musical. Think of what sort of numbers make musicals great.” And so on…
Andrea Martin is brilliant as Frau Blucher. I wish the Inspector Kemp role had been meatier. Join The Family Business wasn’t my favorite piece, and Transylvania Mania is where the deviation from the original storyline is messiest (I’m talking about the plot and not necessarily the number itself). The scene where The Monster is being introduced on stage is smartly executed and fun, and the Puttin On The Ritz number is just great. I don’t think Megan Mullally really gets to shine until Scene 6, but then that’s likely because the number in Scene 3 is so dissonant for me.
Between trying to ignore how the show was different from the screen version, and focusing on how things were lit or choreographed or being performed, I actually did get swept up in the show a few times. I was absolutely delighted in parts. It might have been easier to get lost in it all if I had been sitting in the orchestra, because the actors weren’t playing so much to the balcony. It was definitely easier getting lost in this than the Taiko Jam Concert at Benaroya Hall…
I will say that I was thrilled by SJT’s performance in a way I hadn’t been for a long time. Actually…I need to say that about the screening of Amaterasu, too. That was outstanding and brilliant and I wish I had gotten to see that live. There’s another story that’s been told in a lot of ways, coupled with trying to present the best elements of the group in concert. I had the sense that I could really appreciate what the artists had created and I was so grateful.
Where I get scared is also where I was largely disapponted by a lot of the performances I saw last weekend…and that is a lot of what my group plays is somewhat repetitive and one-dimensional in that structurally a lot of our pieces are fundamentally the same. It’s the same kind of drumming, or the same other instruments interspersed in between. We draw on our strengths.
The other thought that comes to mind, however, is that a lot of the time audience members want to see something consistent. They want the same core pieces (but also get tired of them after a time) and they want more of the same but different enough to hold their interest over time). When you play the core pieces, people are sated. They are satisfied they got to experience the image they hold of you in your head, but then that’s never enough, especially after a few years, when it’s boring to come see the same group play the same songs. So they want new, innovative pieces. If you get too innovative, though, you’re just not who you were and what everyone enjoyed about you to begin with.
There’s a double edged blade. San Jose had the most discernable variety from piece to piece.
Overall I didn’t see much that took my breath away, not the way it was taken away the first time I saw Zampa Ufujishi or Shidara (to draw on more recent examples). San Jose really moved me this last performance, though.
Not that I think I am doing much better, folks. The pieces I compose and the way I arrange things for the stage is often not so very innovative. The structure of my pieces is fairly consistent and I don’t use the space on stage or even lighting as well as I’d like to be able to in any given production.
Maybe what I learned tonight will be just in time to make a positive difference for Sac Taiko’s 18th. I can at least hope, anyway. Meanwhile, got other stuff to do…and I am currently sleep-typing. Will try to clean this up next time I get a spare minute or few.
OH…and before I forget. I had a corn on the cob that was pretty ang tender and sweet from the place that sells Thai food at Pike’s Place Market, and then I had a crab cocktail at Lowell’s. It seemed pricey before I got it, but it was bowl chock full o’ dungeness crab mat and I was a happy camper.
Yesterday We ate at OHANA, which has great Lava Flows and some tasty (ono?) food.
I debated buying a salmon to bring home…but figure it’s better if I don’t …and I ended up buying some peaches, instead.
*****THIS JUST IN*****
I got an email from a purveyor of fine entertainment tickets in New York. Incidentally, Young Frankenstein is now playing in New York. Funny thing, that. In any case, if you are looking for
TICKETS to see Young Frankenstein (or any of a number of fine productions) ON BROADWAY you might want to try clicking this link: http://www.reedstickets.net